Group: alt.politics.economics
From: "Paul Thomas, CPA"
Date: Monday, October 08, 2007 8:08 AM
Subject: Re: Are the Filthy Rich Necessary?


wrote
>>That there are no book written or movies made of an event that includes -
>>according to you - millions of slaves who became slave owners.....
>>
>>Doesn't that say more about your self-created "fact" than the reality of
>>history?
>
> Evidence, Paul. Where's the evidence for your claim that an absence
> of books or movies about an event makes it not have happened?



I didn't claim that because there are no movies or books about a historical
situation, that it didn't happen. There are billions of historical events
that never make it to screen or paper. But they happened. They just were
insignificant in the grand scheme of things.

But really, there were somewhere in the neighborhood of 4 million slaves in
the US. Out of all the books and movies made, and out of all the programing
on the history channel, you think there'd be one story of the millions that
opted to - of all things - become slave owners themselves.





> As usual, you just lied again. I've posted this before:
>
> "During the war I served in a Kentucky
> regiment in the Federal army. When the war
> broke out, my father owned sixty slaves.
> I had not been back to my old Kentucky
> home for years until a short time ago, when
> I was met by one of my father's old
> negroes, who said to me: 'Master George, you
> say you set us free; but before God,
> I'm worse off than when I belonged to your father.'
> The planters, on the other hand, are contented
> with the change. They say, ' How foolish it was in
> us to go to war for slavery. We get labor cheaper
> now than when we owned the slaves.' How do
> they get it cheaper? Why, in the shape of rents
> they take more of the labor of the negro than they
> could under slavery, for then they were compelled
> to return him sufficient food, clothing and medical
> attendance to keep him well, and were
> compelled by conscience and public opinion, as
> well as by law, to keep him when he
> could no longer work. Now their interest and
> responsibility cease when they have
> got all the work out of him they can."




LMAO - narry one quote that supports your lame "fact" that slaves wanted to
be slave owners.




> I've already posted it, as you know.


What you posted does not support your claim of "fact".




You're a loser. Folks here know it.



--
Have no fear of perfection - you'll never reach it.
----------
Paul A. Thomas, CPA